Thank you for your time with the attached manuscript. Comments should be
-formative- in nature and designed to -strengthen- the manuscript where
necessary. Please make your review comments in CAPS right in the document,
such as:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"The survey clearly demonstrates that people in the area believe
that the sky is, indeed, falling.(THE SURVEY USED IN THE STUDY
APPEARS INAPPROPRIATE; YOU MIGHT TRY "CANNONS SKY SURVEY" INSTEAD AS IT
SEEMS TO BETTER MEASURE SKY FALLING). Richardson's (1923) (THIS RESEARCH
SEEMS DATED -- ARE THERE MORE CURRENT REFERENCES?) findings are congruent
with this research."
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Please return this evaluation form imbedded at the bottom of the
attached document. Evaluate and rate (5=EXCELLENT - 1=POOR) the paper for the
following:
 

_____ Manuscript focuses on issues related to science/science teacher

education.

_____ Manuscript is timely?

_____ Manuscript is significant?

_____ Manuscript is clear, logical, and concise?

_____ Manuscript is accurate in terms of content?

_____ Manuscript is appropriate in length?

_____ Manuscript has an adequate lit. review?

_____ Manuscript reflects appropriate design and methodology?

_____ Manuscript's conclusions are based on results?

_____ Overall rating?

=======================================================================

_____ Accept for publication as submitted

_____ Accept with revisions

_____ Reject, but ask to resubmit after revisions

_____ Reject
 
 

Reviewer's comments:

AS ALWAYS - THANKS FOR MAKING THE EJSE A SUCCESS!!!